The Station Agent * * * *


Director: Tom McCarthy.
Screenplay: Tom McCarthy.
Starring: Peter Dinklage, Patricia Clarkson, Bobby Cannavale, Michelle Williams, Ravin Goodwin, Paul Benjamin, Richard Kind, Josh Pais.

Having just recently gotten into the HBO TV series “Game of Thrones” and finding the character and Golden Globe winning acting of Peter Dinklage very appealing, I decided to look back at one of his major leading roles in The Station Agent. I had seen this film years ago and liked it a lot but on a repeat viewing, I enjoyed it even more.

Fin McBride (Peter Dinklage) is a young man born with dwarfism that has consistently struggled to fit into society. He has a passion for trains and works in a shop selling such items but when his only friend and co-worker dies, he finds that in his late friends will, he has been left an abandoned train depot in rural New Jersey. Looking for solitude, he packs up his things and moves there only to find unusual friendships developing with local struggling artist Olivia (Patricia Clarkson) – trying to overcome a personal tragedy of her own – and Joe (Bobby Cannavale) an overly friendly Cuban hot-dog vendor, desperate for some form of interaction with people.

This plot summary might not sound like much but don’t be fooled into thinking this is an uneventful or boring affair. It’s far from it. Yes, not a lot is going on this film but that exactly the appeal. It’s filled with such attention to detail and strong characterisation that this film is plentiful. I’m a sucker for these type of low-key, subtle and observant dramas and this debut from director Tom McCarthy is a perfect example of that particular sub-genre. It’s a slow moving and thoughtful film that sensitively deals with feelings of loneliness and isolation. To embody the emptiness, McCarthy is aided with three superb lead performances which are poignant and heartfelt but more importantly, realistic. Not a lot is going on in their lives but that’s the very thing that holds your attention. It’s the bond and the relationship they develop with one another that gives this film it’s heart. McCarthy handles the material delicately and seems entirely aware of the appeal that these characters have, as are the performers; Dinklage is an actor with many qualities and it’s great to see him in a rare but well deserved leading role. Patricia Clarkson is always an actress I’ve admired and it baffles me why she isn’t seen more often. The biggest surprise though, is Bobby Cannavale who provides the comic-relief to the suffering of the other two. That being said, this film isn’t the slightest bit depressing despite the subject matter. In fact, it’s a charming and absorbing human tale.

An original and affecting debut from director Tom McCarthy that displays a genuine warmth and respect for struggling individuals. His ability to be both perceptive and humorous is rarely captured so well on screen.

Mark Walker


23 Responses to “The Station Agent * * * *”

  1. Well written review, really descriptive.


  2. ray brayne Says:

    Good film. Loved the laid back pacing. You can see why Finbar would want to live here, easy going, relaxing. Despite his efforts to the contrary, Finbar still manages to fit in. Loved the scene in the bar where he stands “up” for himself. And Michelle Williams! Ah! I have such a crush on her(have you seen “Marilyn”?). If you’re just getting into “Game of Thrones”, wait till you see the mind blowing season 2!


    • Yeah man. A heartwarming little film. The scene you mention in the bar was great and Dinklage nails that frustration in his character perfectly.
      I’ve seen season two of Game of Thrones as well. I done the first two seasons back to back. It’s marvellous stuff and again, Dinklage is superb. Not seen Marilyn yet but I have to admit, Williams has yet to grab me. I don’t dislike her but I’m more drawn to Carey Mulligan’s abilities who I think is very similar.


      • ray brayne Says:

        Like both Carey and Michelle. Cute, sexy, talented. Carey speaks American very well, can’t hurt her career. She was great in “Shame” and Michelle made me forget Monroe in “Marilyn”, if that’s possible. Nice write up Mark. You’ve done three films this week that other bloggers seem to have missed


      • I thought Mulligan was excellent in “Shame” and also “Never Let Me Go”. You should see that if you haven’t already. Here’s a (lazy) review I’d written a while back
        I’ll get around to Marilyn but if truth be told it didn’t quite grab me when it was released bug I’ll give it a chance.
        As for the reviews I’ve posted, I appreciate your checking them out but you should also check out Dan’s (CMrok93) from the other commenters. He done a great review of The Station Agent bit so long ago.


  3. Good review Mark. This is one of those little indies that his it’s own charms and quirks that always seem to work. Especially when you have a great trio of leads like Dinklage, Clarkson, and Cannavale. All are terribly underrated and deserve bigger and better roles in today’s day.


  4. Saw this a few months back. I agree, it’s a surprisingly good little film. Dinklage, Clarkson, and Cannavale all play off each other really well.


  5. Great review! I love Dinklage, I too discovered his talent in Game of Thrones, though I saw him in few other things before that, he was really great especially in hilarious Death at the Funeral. I love Clarkson, she should stop doing silly comedies like Friends with Benefits, she is too good for that.


    • Cheers sati! I’ve been a follower of Clarkson’s for a while and I’m amazed she doesnt get better deals. Dinklage I was aware of but hadn’t seen Death at a Funeral (both versions where apparently he plays the same character?) but in Game Of Thrones he’s marvellous. The real heart in the middle of all the turmoil.


  6. Great review. I’ll check this one out. McCarthy’s The Visitor and Win Win are also very good.


  7. I remember discovering this film by accident and being really impressed with Dinklage, and the whole cast for that matter – another low budget indie walk and talk but the acting was superb and the dialogues just felt genuine. I know these people. I’ve stumbled similarly, fallen down practically. Bobby Cannavale too is someone to watch, he makes the most of small parts and leaves a lasting impression. Clarkson is my all time fav. I still can’t stop watching her in High Art. If you’re interested, check out my review of Roadie with Cannavale – he stands his toes.

    Solid review, nicely to the point. Hey, is this a trend? Can’t beat the good reviews that give you the shots directly. Nice back and forth comments too, some good points about those films – Never Let Me Go is great, and Shame is forthcoming.

    Here’s Roadie if you like:


    • It’s my trend anyway. I normally write long winded reviews but I’ll edit them down and dump a lot of stuff. I enjoy reading in-depths reviews but would rather mine not like that. I want people to know that when they stop by they will get a quick delivery.

      Great little film this though. Everything about it was sharp and genuine. I’ll swing by on your link in a bit. Thanks again Rory.


  8. filmfellahenry Says:

    Nice review dude. I managed to catch the theatrical release and thoroughly enjoyed it; as you said, it showed a real attention to detail and focus on characterisation. I also think it was one of the first things i saw dinklage in and he was brilliant even back then. On a side note: im sure you’ve heard this before, but if you’re a game of thrones fan i strongly recommend avoiding season 2 and starting on the second book instead. They are far superior to the tv show and comprise a trully outstanding story.


    • Thanks again Henry. I too am an admirer of Dinklage. He’s a great actor. As for Game of Thrones, I’ve already seen season 2 and have to say, it didn’t live up to the first. I’m might move onto book 3 though. Thanks for the advice man.


      • filmfellahenry Says:

        No worries mate. GoT is one of those things that will always suffer from translation issues, unless you have can extend each season to 24 eps with 20 mil budget on each (which will never happen). So much was missed from the book in season 2 that even I, a long time fan, struggled to comprehend what they were doing in some places. And it’s a shame because George RR Martin’s story is so good, that it really should be mandatory reading (like Lord Of the Rings for example); yet I fear many will be turned off after season 2. To be honest, I’d even suggest going back and reading book 2 – so much more happens than in the series and it’s done with a literary competence that is truly remarkable.


      • You’ve certainly sold the books well Henry. I might just go back and do that. Thanks for the info my man.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: